Limited Circular debate: newspaper reports

About Celtic | Celtic Committee | Limited liability circular

From Charity status to Business status…

One of the key moments in Celtic history, the decision to change from a charitable trust to the much more commercially-minded limited liability status in 1897 has parallels with the takeover of the club by Fergus McCann from the old board nearly a century later.

Like that landmark, the move was hotly-debated and provoked strong feeling on both sides. In a similar fashion to McCann’s takeover, the move was driven by those who believed that as a club Celtic needed to adapt to what were drastically-changing times in Scottish football.

As Tom Campbell and Pat Woods write:

‘[Celtic’s] success quickly posed another dilemma. Record crowds produced vast sums in revenue, and donations to the charities designated by Brother Walfrid, but ‘amateur’ players were demanding higher remuneration and a new and larger stadium had to be built.
The Scottish League was also formed in 1890 and the legalisation of professional players was recognised in 1893.
Could Celtic survive as a charitable trust in such an era of expansion?
The debate within the club was heartfelt and spirited but in 1897 Celtic became a limited company.’

Campbell and Woods Celtic Football Club 1887-1967 (1998) p. 7

An early account of the idea for the change, and the subsequent debate that ensued, was recorded in the Glasgow Herald, Friday, December 13, 1895:

Limited Circular debate: newspaper reports - The Celtic Wiki