| 05/06 | Celtic 1 (Beattie) | Hearts 1 | ||
| Hearts 2 | Celtic 3 (McManus 2, Pearson) | |||
| Celtic 1 (Hartson) | Hearts 0 | 40th Championship Clinched | ||
| Hearts 3 | Celtic 0 | |||
| 06/07 | Hearts 2 | Celtic 1 (Petrov) | ||
| Celtic 2 (Jarosik, OG) | Hearts 1 | |||
| Hearts 1 | Celtic 2 (Hesselink, Jarosik) | |||
| Celtic 1 (Pressley) | Hearts 3 | |||
| 07/08 | Celtic 5 (Donati, Brown, Hesselink, Nakamura, OG) | Hearts 0 | ||
| Celtic 0 | Hearts 2 | Scottish League Cup Quarter-Finals | ||
| Hearts 1 | Celtic 1 (McDonald) | |||
| Celtic 3 (Hesselink, McDonald, Hinkel) | Hearts 0 | |||
| 08/09 | Hearts 0 | Celtic 2 (Maloney, Caldwell) | ||
| Celtic 1 (McManus) | Hearts 1 | |||
| Hearts 1 | Celtic 1 (Hesselink) | |||
| Celtic 0 | Hearts 0 |